Historic Mill Photo
Established 1930
header image
home
History
menus
Wines
People
customers
Map Button
Photos
Group Tours
Potpourri
Contact Us

Here's what some of our valued customers have
to say about
The Mill!

From S.P. (Art) Fruechtl, Sturgeon Bay

June 24, 2010

Dear Mill Management & Staff,
     Greetings! Just a quick note to say "Job Well Done" regarding our dinner/celebration of Sunday, 6/27.
     I was part of a 4-some with [an] elderly couple celebrating almost 60 years together (Robert Melchior family.)
     Every aspect of the experience was excellent i.e. food service, atmosphere.
     In particular our server showed true professionalism and kindness/patience while attending to "hard of hearing senior citizen[s.]" This really stood out!
Hats off to you and your staff and keep up the good work!

Respectfully,
Art
S.P. Fruechtl, Sturgeon Bay




letter


Mill Sign
From the US Marine Corp League:

November 24, 2009

On behalf of the Detachment 1130 of the  Marine Corps league, we would like to Thank You and your staff for once again putting on a fine dinner for our Birthday Party.

We certainly appreciate your accommodating our group. The service was outstanding and a great time was had by all. Thanks again.

Sincerely,

Julie C. Koch
Assistant Paymaster



From the Egg Harbor Men's Club:

October 21, 2009

Thank You Don & Shelly:

We would like to thank you for all of your help with the Big Cup Scramble.  The Scramble was a huge success. 31 teams were more than we expected.

The profits raised will be put towards our goal of drilling a well. Thank you for your generous donations.

We received a lot of comments about "How much fun it was," and "The scramble was very organized with very nice prizes.

Thank you again for al of your help.

Sincerely,

The Egg Harbor Men's Club
Egg Harbor Indians Baseball Team







Shelly with Bread


Karen Bar
From TripAdvisor.com
May 11, 2009
If you grew up in Wisconsin, you’ll enjoy this classic supper club. Sit at the bar and order a Whiskey Sour: You’ll feel you’ve stepped back in time. When we did that, we were surrounded by locals, people who know each other well. Yet we felt right at home. You won’t find too much that’s chichi or trendy here: What you will find is a filling meal of steak or seafood or chicken with a potato and roll, with a salad for a starter. There are several other such places in Door County, but this one feels like the classic. There is something comforting about The Mill.

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.


From A Happy Family Reunion!

Dear Don &  Shelly,

I want to thank you for hosting our family get-together at The Mill. Thanks also for letting us crowd into your bar for a time to give hugs, get hugs, and exchange greetings. That was very important in making the get-together a success. The Mill was the perfect place for this event.

My meal started with a salad. It seemed someone must have run out to your garden to get mixings so fresh. Topped with delicious dressing we were all completely happy.

My decision on the menu was the prime rib. I kind of hesitated on that choice. Though I love it, I seldom am satisfied with restaurants’ preparation. It was without a doubt the best prime rib I’ve ever had. It was prepared just perfect. Many of the people I was sitting with also had the prime rib and the comments were all the same "…this is delicious, prepared just right, and the serving size is huge." Aunt Dorothy, Cousin Ed Perkins, Aunt Betty, my sister Barb and I were sitting close — we all had the prime rib and rated it THE BEST EVER. I know we all took doggie bags because the portions were so big.

Please give our compliments and thanks to your wonderful servers. Their smiles were greatly appreciated, and their efficiency fantastic. You have put together a darn good crew.

Thanks again… you were very important in making the day so terrific.

Tom





Da Bar






Front of Thank You Card

The Front of Karen's
Thank You Card
 
4/11/09
Dear Shelly and Don,
    A very special thank you for the great dinner for mom.
    You got so many compliments from the family and friends.
    Also the "drumstick" torte was a big favorite!
                        See you soon.
                        My best,
                        Karen Cowan

ps. Mom's favorite dinner was the chicken at The Mill!



From TripAdvisor.com

August 28, 2008
While visiting Door County we came across the Mill Super Club which is where the two highways in the county split which was extremely convenient. Very quaint bar with beautiful woodwork for a few before dinner coctails. Their menu offers everything from steaks, seafood, burgers, and a kids menu. The food was outstanding. We had an opportunity to chat with the owner who was bartending and a very friendly gentleman. The service was very welcoming and friendly. Felt right at home!

This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.




Photo: Don at Bar

photo

From Dorothea Mann
Sturgeon Bay

Thank you for the wonderful service and delicious food you rendered at our St. Ann's Christmas Party!

From Altrusa Club
of Door County

Altrusa Club of Door County thanks you for your recent donation. The success of our club depends on the kindness and generosity of people like you. Funds raised are dispersed to programs and families in Door County. Your support enables our club to continue our work.

Photo of Karen

Don & Shelly Photo
Chrystal VanGheem
Wal-Mart of SturgeonBay

Thank you very much to you and your staff for hosting our Christmas party again. Everyone had a wonderful time, and your staff was very helpful and courteous!


You can contact us by email at

Don@millsupperclub.com

or call The Mill at
(920) 743-5044